Torn between a MacBook and a Windows laptop? Both can work very well; it depends on what you do with it, which programs you need and how long you want to use it. This article lists the differences, including a side that is often forgotten: how they wear and what happens when something breaks.
Blue Apple repairs MacBooks in Amsterdam. Every day we see laptops that have lasted for years, and laptops that are worn out after two. There is something to learn from that.
Use and programs
- MacBook: macOS is tidy and works well with an iPhone and iPad (AirDrop, messages, copy and paste between devices). Office, browsers, Zoom, Teams and most creative programs work on both.
- Windows laptop: more choice in models and prices. Some business packages, special software for devices and many games only work on Windows.
If you still need a Windows program on a Mac, a virtualisation program often makes it possible. See Windows on a Mac.
Battery life and speed
MacBooks with an Apple chip often last a whole working day on one charge and stay cool and quiet. Some Windows laptops manage that too, but it varies a lot per model. A cheap Windows laptop often manages considerably less.
Updates and lifespan
Apple usually supports a Mac for many years with new macOS versions and then for a while with security updates. Windows 11 runs on many laptops, but older models sometimes do not meet the requirements for new versions. In both cases the hardware decides how long it lasts: a good battery, enough memory and storage.
Upgrading and repair
- MacBook: memory and storage are fixed to the logic board; you choose them at purchase. Repairs are very doable, but parts are model-specific, and some parts must be paired after replacement.
- Windows laptop: on many models you can replace memory and storage yourself. Parts differ enormously by brand and model, and for cheap models they are sometimes hard to get.
More about memory and storage: upgrading memory and replacing an SSD or expanding storage.
Security and viruses
Both systems have good built-in security. macOS has standard protection against known malware and only allows apps from known developers without a warning; Windows has Microsoft Defender. You see fewer viruses on a Mac, but phishing and fake alerts happen on both. Keep your system up to date; on both that is the most important protection.
Resale value
MacBooks generally hold their value better. A MacBook a few years old often still fetches a reasonable amount when sold, which partly makes up for the higher purchase price.
Which should you choose?
- Choose a MacBook if you already have an iPhone, value long battery life and need no Windows-only software.
- Choose a Windows laptop if you need specific Windows programs or games, or want to upgrade memory and storage yourself later.
Considering a used MacBook? Also read buying a refurbished MacBook.
What we do at Blue Apple in Amsterdam
We specialise in Apple devices. If your MacBook is broken, we test it and you first hear what is wrong and what it costs. Wondering whether repair still pays off? Read repair your MacBook or buy a new one. More on our page about MacBook repair in Amsterdam.
Frequently asked questions
Is a MacBook harder to learn than Windows?
Most people get used to it within a few days. The biggest difference is the Command key instead of Ctrl.
Can I move my files from Windows to a Mac?
Yes, with Migration Assistant or via an external drive or iCloud.
Does Microsoft Office work on a Mac?
Yes, Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook and Teams all have a Mac version.
